| Year | Winners | Runners Up |
| 2023 | Comberton Village College (Cambridgeshire CSFA) | Kingsdale Foundation School (Inner London CSFA) |
| 2022 | Shenfield High School ( Essex CSFA) | St Peter’s High School (Gloucestershire CSFA) |
| 2021 | Cancelled | Cancelled |
| 2020 | Bournemouth School for Girls and Weatherhead High School | |
| 2019 | St Ivo School (Cambridgeshire CSFA) | Horizon Community College (South Yorkshire CSFA) |
| 2018 | St Ivo School (Cambridgeshire CSFA) | Cramlington Learning Village (Northumberland CSFA) |
| 2017 | Frome College (Somerset CSFA) | Thomas Telford School (Shropshire CSFA) |
| 2016 | St Bede’s RC High School (Lancashire CSFA) | Kings’ School (Hampshire CSFA) |
| 2015 | St Bede’s RC High School (Lancashire CSFA) | Stratford Upon Avon School (Warwickshire CSFA) |
| 2014 | Queens’ School (Hertfordshire CSFA) | Heckmondwike Grammar School Academy (West Yorkshire CSFA) |
| 2013 | Maiden Erlegh School (Berkshire CSFA) | Laurence Jackson School (Cleveland CSFA) |
| 2012 | Maiden Erlegh School (Berkshire CSFA) | Countesthorpe Community College (Leicestershire CSFA) |
| 2011 | South Holderness Technology College (Humberside CSFA) | Westlands School (Kent CSFA) |
| 2010 | William Farr School (Lincolnshire CSFA) | Thomas Telford School (Shropshire CSFA) |
| 2009 | St Wilfrid’s CE High School (Lancashire CSFA) | Winston Churchill Sports College (Surrey CSFA) |
| 2008 | Kirkley High School (Suffolk CSFA) | Bridgnorth Endowed School (Shropshire CSFA) |
| 2007 | Church Stretton School (Shropshire CSFA) | Katharine Lady Berkeley’s School (Gloucestershire CSFA) |
| 2006 | Meadowhead School (South Yorkshire CSFA) | Aylsham High School (Norfolk CSFA) |
| 2005 | Frome Community College (Somerset CSFA) | Rivington & Blackrod School (Lancashire CSFA) |
| 2004 | Notre Dame School (Merseyside CSFA) | Kingsfield School (Gloucestershire CSFA) |
| 2003 | Abraham Darby School (Shropshire CSFA) | Little Heath School (Berkshire CSFA) |
| 2002 | Frome Community College (Somerset CSFA) | Countesthorpe College (Leicestershire CSFA) |
| 2001 | Bridgnorth Endowed School (Shropshire CSFA) | Castle Manor School (Suffolk CSFA) |
| 2000 | Helsby High School (Cheshire CSFA) | Guildford County School (Surrey CSFA) |
| 1999 | Meole Brace School (Shropshire CSFA) | Holmfirth School (West Yorkshire CSFA) |
| 1998 | Valley School (Nottinghamshire CSFA) | Darrick Wood School (Kent CSFA) |
| 1997 | Montgomery High School (Lancashire CSFA) | Archbishop Grimshaw School (West Midlands CSFA) |
| 1996 | West Bridgford School (Nottinghamshire CSFA) | St John Bosco School (Merseyside CSFA) |
