| Year | Winners | Runners Up |
| 2023 | Weydon School (Hampshire CSFA) | Samuel Whitbread Academy (Bedfordshire CSFA) |
| 2022 | Brooke House College (Leicestershire CSFA) | Hurstmere School (Kent CSFA) |
| 2021 | Cancelled | Cancelled |
| 2020 | Hampton School and Brooke House College | |
| 2019 | Thomas Estley Community College (Leicestershire CSFA) | John Spence Community High School (North Tynside CSFA) |
| 2018 | Calday Grange Grammar School (Merseyside CSFA) | Whitgift School (Surrey CSFA) |
| 2017 | The Windsor Boys’ School (Berkshire CSFA) | Cardinal Hume Catholic School (Durham CSFA) |
| 2016 | Thomas Telford School (Shropshire CSFA) | Samuel Whitbread Academy (Bedfordshire CSFA) |
| 2015 | West Derby School (Merseyside CSFA) | Beechen Cliff School (Somerset CSFA) |
| 2014 | St Francis Xavier’s College (Merseyside CSFA) | Whitgift School (Surrey CSFA) |
| 2013 | Thomas Telford School (Shropshire CSFA) | Chelmer Valley High School (Essex CSFA) |
| 2012 | West Derby School (Merseyside CSFA) | St Martin’s School (Essex CSFA) |
| 2011 | Malet Lambert School (Humberside CSFA) | Broadlands School (Somerset CSFA) |
| 2010 | Harefield Academy (Middlesex CSFA) | Manchester Grammar School (Greater Manchester CSFA) |
| 2009 | Wright Robinson Sports College (Greater Manchester CSFA) | Howard of Effingham School (Surrey CSFA) |
| 2008 | Torquay Boys’ Grammar School (Devon CSFA) | Rock Ferry High School (Merseyside CSFA) |
| 2007 | Rushcliffe School (Nottinghamshire CSFA) | Forest School (Berkshire CSFA) |
| 2006 | Impington Village College (Cambridgeshire CSFA) | St Margaret’s C of E High School (Merseyside CSFA) |
| 2005 | Weston Park Boys’ School (Hampshire CSFA) | Montgomery High School (Lancashire CSFA) |
| 2004 | Shenfield High School (Essex CSFA) | Cramlington Community School (Northumberland CSFA) |
| 2003 | Stoke High School (Suffolk CSFA) | Codsall Community High School (Staffordshire CSFA) |
| 2002 | Arrow Vale High School (Worcestershire CSFA) | Kingshurst City Tech College (West Midlands CSFA) |
| 2001 | Kingsdown School (Wiltshire CSFA) | Cardinal Heenan School (Merseyside CSFA) |
| 2000 | St Aloysius College (Inner London CSFA) | Arnold Hill School (Nottinghamshire CSFA) |
| 1999 | Cramlington High School | Crown Woods School (Inner London CSFA) |
| 1998 | Blue Coat School Liverpool | Douay Martyrs RC School (Middlesex CSFA) |
| 1997 | City School Sheffield (South Yorkshire CSFA) | |
| William Parker School (Sussex CSFA) | ||
| 1996 | Larkmead School (Oxfordshire CSFA) | St Francis Xavier School (Merseyside CSFA) |
| 1995 | Cardinal Heenan School (Merseyside CSFA) | |
| St Michael’s School (Hertfordshire CSFA) | ||
| 1994 | Barking Abbey School (Essex CSFA) | St Theodore’s School (Lancashire CSFA) |
| 1993 | Farringdon School (Durham CSFA) | |
| Dr Challoner’s Grammar School (Buckinghamshire CSFA) | ||
| 1992 | Torquay Grammar School (Devon CSFA) | De La Salle School (Merseyside CSFA) |
| 1991 | De La Salle School (Merseyside CSFA) | Kingsthorpe Upper School (Northamptonshire CSFA) |
| 1990 | Campion RC High School (Merseyside CSFA) | Cowes High School (Hampshire CSFA) |
| 1989 | Chester RC High School (Cheshire CSFA) | Emerson Park School (Essex CSFA) |
| 1988 | St Aidan’s School (Durham CSFA) | |
| Weston Park School (Hampshire CSFA) | ||
| 1987 | Sir William Collins School (Inner London CSFA) | |
| Guthlaxton College (Leicestershire CSFA) | ||
| 1986 | Kirk Balk School (South Yorkshire CSFA) | |
| Raynes Park High School (Surrey CSFA) | ||
| 1985 | Heathfield High School (Durham CSFA) | Stanground School (Cambridgeshire CSFA) |
| 1984 | Hylton Red House School (Durham CSFA) | Stanground School (Cambridgeshire CSFA) |
| 1983 | Raynes Park High School (Surrey CSFA) | Bishop Challoner High School (Merseyside CSFA) |
| 1982 | Fitzalan School (South Glamorgan CSFA) | Beaumont High School (Cheshire CSFA) |
| 1981 | Washwood Heath School (West Midlands CSFA) | City of Portsmouth Boys’ School (Hampshire CSFA) |
| 1980 | McEntree High School (Essex CSFA) | Cardinal Heenan High School (West Yorkshire CSFA) |
| 1979 | Public Secondary School (Devon CSFA) | Riddings School (Humberside CSFA) |
| 1978 | Kenton High School (Northumberland CSFA) | St Bonaventure’s School (Essex CSFA) |
| 1977 | Holloway School (Inner London CSFA) | |
| Woodlands School (West Midlands CSFA) | ||
| 1976 | Coalville Upper School (Leicestershire CSFA) | |
| Easington Secondary School (Durham CSFA) | ||
| 1975 | Easington Secondary School (Durham CSFA) | |
| Scott Lidgett Secondary School (Surrey CSFA) | ||
| 1974 | Coalville Upper School (Leicestershire CSFA) | |
| Cumberland School (Essex CSFA) |
