| Year | Winners | Runners Up |
| 2019 | Cardinal Newman Catholic School | Acland Burghley School |
| 2018 | Kingsdale Foundation School (Inner London CSFA) | Northampton School for Boys (Northamptonshire CSFA) |
| 2017 | Thomas Telford School (Shropshire CSFA) | Poynton High School (Cheshire CSFA) |
| 2016 | St Aloysius College (Inner London CSFA) | Sandwell Academy (West Midlands CSFA) |
| 2015 | Oxford Academy (Oxfordshire CSFA) | St Ignatius College (Middlesex CSFA) |
| 2014 | Bruntcliffe High School (West Yorkshire CSFA) | St Aloysius College (Inner London CSFA) |
| 2013 | William Howard School (Cumbria CSFA) | Alameda Middle School (Bedfordshire CSFA) |
| 2012 | Audenshaw School (Greater Manchester CSFA) | Malet Lambert School (Humberside CSFA) |
| 2011 | Sandwell Academy (West Midlands CSFA) | Priestnall School (Greater Manchester CSFA) |
| 2010 | Trinity School (Cumbria CSFA) | Kibworth High School (Leicestershire CSFA) |
| 2009 | St Thomas the Apostle College (Inner London CSFA) | South Hunsley High School (Humberside CSFA) |
| 2008 | South Wigston High School (Leicestershire CSFA) | Shenfield High School (Essex CSFA) |
| 2007 | Riddlesdown School (Inner London CSFA) | Canford Heath Middle School (Dorset CSFA) |
| 2006 | Mosslands School (Merseyside CSFA) | Nunthorpe School (Cleveland CSFA) |
| 2005 | St Bede’s RC Middle School (Worcestershire CSFA) | Mount Grace School (Leicestershire CSFA) |
| 2004 | Thomas Telford School (Shropshire CSFA) | Bideford College (Devon CSFA) |
| 2003 | Laurence Jackson Sports College (Cleveland CSFA) | Milton Cross School (Hampshire CSFA) |
| 2002 | St Ignatius College (Middlesex CSFA) | Bradon Forest School (Wiltshire CSFA) |
| 2001 | Springfield School (Hampshire CSFA) | George Stephenson School (Northumberland CSFA) |
| 2000 | St Thomas the Apostle College (Inner London CSFA) | Crawshaw School (West Yorkshire CSFA) |
| 1999 | Meadows School (Derbyshire CSFA) | Welling School (Kent CSFA) |
| 1998 | Nicholas Chamberlaine School (Warwickshire CSFA) | Kings School (Cheshire CSFA) |
| 1997 | Audenshaw High School (Greater Manchester CSFA) | Eastbrook School (Essex CSFA) |
| 1996 | Bradon Forest School (Wiltshire CSFA) | Woodside School (Essex CSFA) |
| 1995 | N/A | |
| 1994 | Hadrian Park Middle School (Northumberland CSFA) | St Wilfrid’s School (Durham CSFA) |
| 1993 | St Benedict’s School (Merseyside CSFA) | |
| | Pelton Roseberry School (Durham CSFA) | |
| 1992 | Wood Green High School (West Midlands CSFA) | Hamel Hempstead School (Hertfordshire CSFA) |
